Paragrah reference used in:-
Electronic Copy
Supporting Documents Reference No
Title
Author
Footnote Reference used in the Preliminary Statement of Case
Footnote Reference used in the Statement of Reasons
the AIP to Scottish Executive dated Oct 2001
the report, "A Vision for Edinburgh", by tie dated Sept 2002
Y
T1
Integrated Transport Initiative for Edinburgh and South East Scotland. Report by Transport Initiatives Edinburgh - A Vision for Edinburgh. 30 September 2002
Transport Initiatives Edinburgh Ltd
11, 24, 26, 50, 56, 57, 62, 63, 106, 112, 113, 124, 158, 159, 160, 161, 164, 194, 195, 197, 205, 220, 221
2, 5
Y
T1a
Integrated Transport Initiative for Edinburgh and South East Scotland Preliminary Report to the City of Edinburgh Council. 17 September 2002.
Transport Initiatives Edinburgh Ltd
2.2, 4.1
Y
T2
Integrated Transport Initiative for Edinburgh and South - East Scotland. Application to the Scottish Executive for Approval in Principle. October 2001.
City of Edinburgh Council.
9, 142
1.6, 5.1
Y
T3
Integrated Transport Initiative for Edinburgh and South - East Scotland. Application to the S Exec for Approval in Principle. Appraisal Summary Table and Technical Report. October 2001.
City of Edinburgh Council.
9, 146
1.1, 5.1
Y
T4
New Transport Initiative - Phase 1: Final Report. 2000.
City of Edinburgh Council.
143
1, 3.1
5.1
Y
T5
New Transport Initiative - Technical Report on Phase 1. 2000.
City of Edinburgh Council.
135, 141, 152
2.2.2, 3.7
5.1
Synopsis available now, main report available end 2003/early 2004
T6
City of Edinburgh Council Local Transport Strategy. 2003
City of Edinburgh Council.
68, 69, 70, 71, 72, 75, 77, 192
Y
T7a
T7b
T7c
T7d
Local Transport Strategy 2004-2007
City of Edinburgh Council.
Y
T8
Letter to Councillor Burns from the Minister for Enterprise, Transport and Lifelong Learning. March 2002.
The Minister for Enterprise, Transport and Lifelong Learning
10
1.1
Y
T9
Draft SESTRAN Regional Transport Strategy. 2003
The SESTRAN Authorities
48, 51, 53, 54, 55
Y
T10
Edinburgh and the Lothians Structure Plan. Draft for Consultation. December 2001
Edinburgh and the Lothians Structure Plan Joint Liaison Committee
2.1.3
3.2
Y
T11
West Edinburgh Planning Framework Consultation Draft. 2002.
The Scottish Executive.
3.1
Y
T12
SESTRAN Interim Regional Transport Strategy. 2001
The SESTRAN Authorities
2.3.1
3.2
Y
T13
Edinburgh and the Lothians Structure Plan2015. Finalised Plan. 17 March 2003
Edinburgh and the Lothians Structure Plan Joint Liaison Committee
52, 58, 59, 60, 61
Y
T14
Feasibility Study for a North Edinburgh Rapid Transit Solution. July 2001
Andersen, Steer Davies Gleave, Mott MacDonald
7.1
Y
T15
West Edinburgh Tram Prospectus to Scottish Executive, CEC. June 2002.
Arup
7.1
Y
T16
SE Edinburgh Tram Public Transport Fund Bid to SExec, CEC. August 2002.
Arup
7.1
Y
T17
Forecasts prepared for CEC & SEEL. July 2001.
Business Strategies Ltd.
102, 103, 104, 105
2.2.2
2.1
Y
T18
Review of Edinburgh Transport / Economy Interaction Studies
Centre for European, Regional and Transport Economics, University of Kent (Professor Roger Vickerman)
190, 231
Y
T19
Key Sectors: Report of Consultation Programme. Report to the Executive of the Council. 13 August 2002.
City of Edinburgh Council.
110, 111
2.1
Y
T20
A Vision for Edinburgh - A City Plan for the Next Five Years. 2000
City of Edinburgh Council.
2.1.2
3.3
Y
T21
NTI: Next Steps. Report to Council Executive. 11 September 2001
City of Edinburgh Council.
4.1
Y
T22
Edinburgh's Transport Choices - Consultation Leaflet. 1999.
City of Edinburgh Council.
3.2.3, 3.3.1
Y
T23
City Strategy – Two Years On
City of Edinburgh Council.
2.1.1
Y
T24
Report to Transportation Committee by Director of City Development, 31 May 1999
City of Edinburgh Council.
140
2.1.4
Y
T25
Edinburgh and the Lothians Structure Plan - Major Issues report
City of Edinburgh Council.
2.1.3
T26
Number Not Used
Y
T27
Edinburgh Integrated Transport Initiative - Economic Impact of Preferred Option - Sept 2003 (Version 4)
David Simmonds Consultancy
176, 177, 179, 189, 191, 230
Y
T28
A New Deal for Transport: Better for Everyone: White Paper
DETR
2.2.2
Y
T29
Transport and the Economy, SACTRA, DETR 1999
DETR
3.5.1
Y
T30
Local Economic Scoping Study
DTZ PIEDA
3.5.1
Y
T31
East Lothian Council Local Transport Strategy. 2001
East Lothian Council
3.2
Y
T32
Fife Council Local Transport Strategy. 2001
Fife Council
3.2
Y
T33
Midlothian Council Local Transport Strategy. 2001
Midlothian Council
3.2
Y
T34
CEC Land Use and Transport Interaction Model, Functional Specification. June 2002.
MVA and the David Simmonds Consultancy
2.2, 5.2
Y
T35
CEC Land Use and Transport Interaction Model, Base Year Calibration and Validation Report. MVA, David Simmonds Consultancy, June 2002.
MVA and the David Simmonds Consultancy
2.2, 5.2
Y
T36
Use of CEC / tie LUTI model - ITI Results Update. June 2003
MVA and the David Simmonds Consultancy
162, 163, 178, 211, 213, 216, 230
Y
T37
CEC Land Use and Transport Interaction Model - Overview of the Model - August 2003
MVA and the David Simmonds Consultancy
230
Y
T38
CEC Land Use and Transport Interaction Model - Functional Specification - August 2003
MVA and the David Simmonds Consultancy
230
Y
T39
Joint Authorities Transportation and Environmental Study: Strategies Study Final Report. 1992
MVA Consultancy
133, 134
2.1.3
5.1, 5.2
Y
T40
Road User Charging Study - Inception Report
MVA Consultancy
3.4.1
Y
T41
Road User Charging Study – Initial Transport Modelling Report
MVA Consultancy
3.4.1
Y
T42
Road User Charging Study – Second Transport Modelling Report
MVA Consultancy
3.4.1
Y
T43
Road User Charging Study – Third Transport Modelling Report
MVA Consultancy
3.4.1
Y
T44
Report for Transport Initiatives Edinburgh. September 2002
Partnerships UK
1.3, 9.2
Y
T45
Report Following Face To Face Interviews with Key Stakeholders in the Edinburgh Business Community
Robert Gordon University
4.2.1, 4.2.7
Y
T46
Scottish Borders Council Local Transport Strategy. 2001
Scottish Borders Council
3.2
Y
T47
Road User Charging Using the Edinburgh City Centre Paramics Model
SIAS
4.4.4
Y
T48
Examining the Economic Impacts of Road User Charging and Public Transport Investment in Edinburgh
Steer Davies Gleave
3.5.1
Y
T49
Framework Analysis of Non Rail Projects in SESTRAN Area, Objectives and Strategy Development, Working Note 10. 2002.
Steer Davies Gleave, Babtie Group
7.1
Y
T50
Client Support Services, NTI Business Case: Project Definition Sheets. 2002.
Steer Davies Gleave, Babtie Group
7.1
Not Available
T51
Stirling Council Local Transport Strategy. 2001
Stirling Council
3.2
Y
T52
Road Charging Options for London – A Technical Assessment, Stationery Office 2000 – Executive Summary
The Government Office for London
4.4.1
Y
T53
Initial Assessment of RUC Scheme Design Options for Edinburgh. 2001
The Ian Catling Consultancy
4.4.1, 4.4.2, 6.2.2
8.3
Y
T54
Scotland's Transport, Delivering Improvements. 2002.
The Scottish Executive.
39, 40, 41, 42
3.1
Y
T55
Report to Steering Group 22 June 2001
The SESTRAN Authorities
4.2.8
T56
Number Not Used
Y
T57
Assessment of the Effects of Road User Charging and the Transport Investment Package Proposals on Social Inclusion – Recommendations for Consultation and Appraisal
TRi, Napier University
4.2.9
Y
T58
Public Cons Strategy - Phase II, Preparatory Market Research. July 2001
University of Westminster
219
6.1
Y
T59
Public Cons Strategy - Phase III, Regional Market Research. April 2002
University of Westminster
165, 167, 219
6.1
Y
T60
Public Cons Strategy - Ph IV, Strategic Regional Consultation. Sept 2002
University of Westminster
219
6.2
Y
T61
Road User Charging for Edinburgh – Public Consultation Report
University of Westminster
4.2.1
Y
T62
Appraisal of Strategies for Travel To and Within Edinburgh. 2000.
W. S. Atkins
4.6.2
3.2, 7.1
Y
T63
Appraisal of Strategies for Travel To and Within Edinburgh - Profiles of Expenditure and Income. 2000.
W. S. Atkins
4.6.1
7.1
Not Available
T64
West Lothian Council Local Transport Strategy. 2001
West Lothian Council
3.2
Y
T65
European Regional Prospects, ERECO Group of leading research institutes. August 2001
ERECO
100
2.1.1
2.1
T66
Number Not Used
Not available - paper copies generally available through Lothian libraries
T67
Lothian Structure Plan 1994 Written Statement. December 1997.
Edinburgh and the Lothians Structure Plan Joint Liaison Committee
90, 91, 135, 137
2.1.3
5.1
Y
T68
Consultation on Public – Private Partnership
Andersen
5.2
Y
T69
Preliminary Financial Model
Andersen
4.6.1, 4.6.4
Y
T70
Phase 1 Air Quality Action Plan for Area designated December 2000. June 2002
City of Edinburgh Council.
2.3
Y
T71
Air Quality Management: Stage 4 Report and Action Plan. Report to the Executive of the Council. 13 August 2002
City of Edinburgh Council.
123, 124
2.3
Y
T72
City of Edinburgh Council Local Transport Strategy. 2001
City of Edinburgh Council.
2.2.1, 4.3.1
3.3
Y
T73
Edinburgh's Transport Choices, Interim LTS 2000 to 2003. 1999.
City of Edinburgh Council.
5.1
Y
T74
On Route, The City of Edinburgh Council Local Transport Strategy. 19 Oc 2000
City of Edinburgh Council.
147, 148, 208
5.1
Y
T75
Road User Charging – Potential Revenue Income
Colin Buchanan & Partners
4.6.1, 4.6.3
Y
T76
First Interim Report - Cordon Entry Point Arrangements (Draft)
Colin Buchanan & Partners
4.4.5
Y
T77
NTI Accessibility Analysis. 2001
Derek Halden Consultancy
131, 132
4.5
5.4
Y
T78
ITI Preliminary Business Case. September 2002.
Grant Thornton.
5.2
Y
T79
‘Moving Forward’ - A Transport Strategy for Lothian. 1994
Lothian Regional Council
138
2.2.3
5.1
Y
T80
NTI – LUTI Model Results: Compendium of Results. September 2002
MVA Consultancy
5.4
Y
T81
Delivering ITI’s Through Road User Charging - Consultation & Approval Process. Guidance for Local Authorities. August 2001. Initial Draft
Scottish Executive Development Department.
4, 5, 6, 43, 45
1.3
Y
T82
The Integrated Transport Bill – The Executive’s Proposals
Scottish Executive Development Department.
Y
T83
Approval in Principle Letter - December 2002
Scottish Executive
14, 15, 16
3
Y
T84
City of Edinburgh Council Minutes - 17th October 2002
City of Edinburgh Council.
12, 117, 134
Y
T85
Transport (Scotland) Act 2001
Scottish Executive
8, 23, 27,28, 29, 30, 31, 33, 35, 36, 37, 38, 66, 67, 225
Y
T86
Report of Hearing into Objections to Road Traffic Regulation Orders for Central Edinburgh - July 2003
115, 116, 118, 120, 125, 134
Not Available
T87
Final Report by the City Centre Agency Steering Group - January 1999
Y
T88
Guidance on Local Transport Strategies and Road Traffic Reduction Report - February 2000
Scottish Executive Development Department.
64
Y
T89
Road user Charging - Consultation on Exemption Regulations Under Section 54 of the Transport (Scotland) Act 2001
Scottish Executive Development Department.
171
Y
T90
Congestion Charging Initial Review Preferred Strategy - 2003
Halcrow Group
Y
T91
The West Edinburgh Planning Framework - March 2003
The Scottish Executive.
46, 47
Y
T92
Minutes of the City of Edinburgh Council meeting of 18th September 2003
City of Edinburgh Council.
18, 172, 193
4
Y
T93
Progress during 2003 and Proposed Charging Order
Transport Initiatives Edinburgh Ltd
114, 186, 196
1, 5
Y
T94
Integrated Transport Initiative: Update, Local Transport Strategy 2004 to 2007 and proposed publication of Congestion Charging Order
City of Edinburgh Council.
17, 76, 79
Y
T95
Road User Charging (Consultation and Publication) (Scotland) Regulations 2003
Scottish Executive
21, 32
Y
T96
Rural West Local Plan
City of Edinburgh Council.
80, 81, 82, 83, 84
Y
T97
Strategy and Action Plan for Edinburgh City Centre April 2003 - May 2008
Edinburgh City Centre Management Company
86, 87, 88
Y
T98
Air Quality Management Action Plan. Report to the Executive of the Council. July 2003
City of Edinburgh Council.
121, 122, 124, 182, 184, 185
T99
Number Not Used
Y
T100
Minutes of the City of Edinburgh Council meeting of 29 July 2003
City of Edinburgh Council.
183, 187
Not currently available - available early 2004
T101
ITI Updated Business Case. 2003.
Grant Thornton.
169, 198, 201, 202, 210, 217, 229
T102
Number Not Used
Y
T103
Scottish Transport Appraisal Guidance - September 2003
Scottish Executive
Y
T104
Statement of Reasons - 3 October 2003
Transport Initiatives Edinburgh Ltd
20
Y
T105
Minutes of Meeting of SESTRAN Steering Group - 27 June 2003
SESTRAN
49
Y
T106
Making the Connections: Final Report on Transport and Social Exclusion - February 2003
Social Exclusion Unit - Office of the Deputy Prime Minister
128, 130
Not currently available - available early 2004
T107
Census Data
93, 94, 95, 96, 97, 97, 98, 129
Y
T108
Abstarct from "Edinburgh Facts and Figures 1998"
City of Edinburgh Council.
143, 144
Y
T109
Congestion Charging 6 months on - 23 October 2003
Transport for London
218
Y
T110
Local Transport Strategy 2004 -2007 - Draft for Consultation
City of Edinburgh Council.
65, 203
Y
T111
Edinburgh and Lothians Structure Plan 2015 - Supporting Statement - March 2003
Edinburgh and the Lothians Structure Plan Joint Liaison Committee
89, 92, 99, 101, 108, 109
Y
T112
Edinburgh congestion charging scheme: report on consultation and programme for 2004
Transport Initiatives Edinburgh Ltd
Y
T113
ITI Public Consultation - Report on Methodology
Weber Shandwick
Y
T114
ITI Public Consultation - Tabulation of Comments
Weber Shandwick
Y
T115
ITI Public Consultation - Tabulation of Stakeholder Responses
Weber Shandwick
Y
T116
ITI Public Consultation - Media Analysis
Weber Shandwick
Y
T117
Consultation Comments with Names of Objectors
Weber Shandwick
Y
T118
Report on Leaflet Distribution and Checking
Weber Shandwick
Y
T119
"Opportunities to See" Analysis
Weber Shandwick
Y
T120
Proposed Mitigation Measures Report
Halcrow Group

 

 

Y
T121
LUTI Model - Compendium of Results
MVA Consultancy
Y
T122
Report on Market Research Exercise
University of Westminster
Y
T123
Consultation Draft Charging Order
City of Edinburgh Council.
Y
T124
Report to the City of Edinburgh Council - Edinburgh Congestion Charging Order - Draft Order - 22nd January 2004
City of Edinburgh Council.
Y
T125
Congestion Charging - Proposed Scope and Format of Public Inquiry
City of Edinburgh Council.
Y
T126
Preliminary Statement of Case
City of Edinburgh Council.
Y
T127
Edinburgh 2020 - What do you want Edinburgh City Region to be like in 20 years?
City of Edinburgh Council.
       
Y
T128
Part IV Environment Act 1995, Local Air Quality Management Revised Policy Guidance, Feb 2003
HMSO
       
Y
T129
Review of Social and Community Transport in Edinburgh, 2001
Steer Davies Gleave
       
Y
T130
Transport Policies and Programme TTP 10 1993-1998
Lothian Regional Council
       
Y
T131
Transport Policies and Programme TTP 10A 1994-1999
Lothian Regional Council
       
Y
T132
Environment Act 1995
HMSO
       
Y
T133
Photograph of installation of camera at Dean Bridge
Transport Initiatives Edinburgh Ltd
       
Y
T134
Photograph of installation of camera at Home Street
Transport Initiatives Edinburgh Ltd
       
Y
T135
Environmental Appraisal of Mitigation Measures - Feb 2004
Halcrow Group
       
Y
T136
Cordon Design Report
Halcrow Group
       
Y
T137
Supplementary Design Report on Cordon Crossing Points inc Environmental Appraisal
Halcrow Group
       
Y
T138
Interim Appraisal Report
Halcrow Group
       
Y
T139
City of Edinburgh Council - Edinburgh Congestion Charging Order - Draft Order - 22nd January 2004 Council Decision
City of Edinburgh Council.
       
Y
T140
Report to City of Edinburgh Council - Edinburgh Congestion Charging Order - 18th March 2004
City of Edinburgh Council.
       
Y
T141
SESTRAN Upfront Buses appraisal - Initial Draft For Comments - March 2004
Steer Davies Gleave
       
Y
T142
Traffic Statistics
Scottish Executive
       
Y
T143
Structure Plan Modifications January 2004
Edinburgh and the Lothians Structure Plan Joint Liaison Committee
       
Y
T144
Final Draft Charging Order
City of Edinburgh Council.
       
Y
T145
Peak Hour Flows
TRi Napier University
       
Y
T146
Relevant Map
City of Edinburgh Council.
       
Y
T147
Original Cordon Crossing Plans
City of Edinburgh Council.
       
Y
T148
Amended Cordon Crossing Plans
City of Edinburgh Council.
       
Y
T149
Original Cornwallis Place Plan
City of Edinburgh Council.
       
Y
T150
Amended Cornwallis Place Plan
City of Edinburgh Council.
       
Y
T151
Original Holyrood Plan
City of Edinburgh Council.
       
Y
T152
Amended Holyrood Plan
City of Edinburgh Council.
       
Y
T153
ITI Process Flow Chart
City of Edinburgh Council.
       
Y
T154
Travel Choices for Scotland White Paper
The Scottish Office
       
Y
T155
Road Pricing - The Economic and Technical Possibilities - 1964
The Ministry of Transport
       
Y
T156
Economic Impact of ECCS / ITI Package - March 2004
David Simmonds Consultancy
       
Y
T157
NTI – LUTI Model Results: Compendium of Results.
March 2004 MVA Consultancy
       
Y
T158
Letter dated 27th December 2001 to CEC Chief Executive
Scottish Executive
       
Y
T159
Press Release - Scottish Executive March 2003
Scottish Executive
       
Y
T160
Cordon Crossing Layout Drawings - 2001
Colin Buchanan & Partners
       
Y
T161
Environmental Appraisal of Cordon Crossing Points
Halcrow Group
       
Y
T162
Hospital Parking Charges
Halcrow Group
       
Y
T163
Final Draft Local Transport Startegy as reported to Council 22nd January 2004
City of Edinburgh Council.
       
Y
T164
Congestion Charging in Edinburgh - Demonstration Report - March 2004
The Ian Catling Consultancy
       
Y
T165
Minute for CEC Meeting 22nd January 2004 - Congestion Charging
City of Edinburgh Council.
       
Y
T166
The Transport (Scotland) Act 2001 (Commencement No.1 Transitional Provisions and Savings) Order 2001 (S.S.I 2201/132)
Scottish Executive
       
Y
T167
UK Aviation White Paper - The future of air transport
HMSO
       
Y
T168
Central Edinburgh Traffic Management Proposals : Notes on Issues Relating to Air Quality
Professor Seaton
       
Y
T169
A Note on Asthma and Air Pollution
Professor Seaton
       
Y
T170
Letter dated 15th March 2004 re Road User Charging Model
Deloitte MCS Limited
       
Y
T171
Minute for CEC Meeting of 18th September 2003 - CETM proposals City of Edinburgh Council.        
Y
T172
Congestion Charging - Update on scheme impacts and operations - February 2004
Transport for London
       
Y
T173
Review and Option Analysis of Edinburgh South Suburban Railway - Final Report - 29th March 2004
Atkins
       
Y
T174
Inner Cordon Crossing Points, World Heritage Site and Controlled Parking Zones (existing central and peripheral and proposed zones) Plan
Halcrow Group
       
Y
T175
Evolution of the Investment Package in the Business Case
City of Edinburgh Council.
       
Y
T176
City Development Department Organisational Chart
City of Edinburgh Council.
Y
T177
City of Edinburgh Council Revenue and Capital Expenditure
City of Edinburgh Council.
Y
T178
Examples of Bus Integration - leaflets issued by Lothian Buses
Lothian Buses
Y
T179
Impacts Monuitoring - second annual report
Transport for London
Y
T180
Observer article 26-01-03
The Observer
Y
T181
Derivation of RTS Table
City of Edinburgh Council.
Y
T182
tie Role and Structure
Transport Initiatives Edinburgh Ltd
Y
T183
Tram Line 3
City of Edinburgh Council.
Y
T184
SESTRAN Family Tree
City of Edinburgh Council.
Y
T185
Hermiston Gait Plan
City of Edinburgh Council.
Y
T186
Noise Assessment
Halcrow Group
Y
T187
Use of Congestion Charging Revenues in Year 1 of Operation
Grant Thornton.
Y
T188
Key Sectors Report
City of Edinburgh Council.
Y
T189
Proposed Edinburgh Congestion Charging System
Transport Initiatives Edinburgh Ltd
Y
T190
Central Area Controlled Parking Plan
City of Edinburgh Council.
Y
T191
CACZ Traffic Zones Plan
City of Edinburgh Council.
Y
T192
Edinburgh City Local Plan Project Brief
City of Edinburgh Council.
Y
T193
Finalised Rural West Edinburgh Local Plan Action Plan (June 2003)
City of Edinburgh Council.
Y
T194
CEC Parking Standards (Sep 1999)
City of Edinburgh Council.
Y
T195
Tram Contributions - Draft Planning Policy Guidance (April 2004)
City of Edinburgh Council.
Y
T196
SPPI The Planning System (2002)
Scottish Executive Development Department.
Y
T197
Edinburgh and Lothians Structure Plan 2015 Action Plan (1a) Interim Update (February 2004)
Edinburgh and the Lothians Structure Plan Joint Liaison Committee
Y
T198
SDD Circular 24/1985 Development in the Countryside and Green Belts
Scottish Development Department.
Y
T199
SODD Circulat 12/1996 Town and Country Planning (Scotland) Act 1972 Planning Agreements
Scottish Executive
Y
T200
SODD Circular 4/1998 The Use of Conditions in Planning Permissions
Scottish Executive
Y
T201
New Base/New Design Comparison Spreadsheet
Halcrow Group
Y
T202
New Base/New Design + Mitigation Comparison Spreadsheet
Halcrow Group
Not Available Electronicaly
T203
Environmental Assessment Guidelines
Y
T204
Supplementary statement by Andrew Holmes re Forth Bridge Tolls or Charge Offset Issues
City of Edinburgh Council.
Y
T205
2003 Project Appraisal Work and DM2 development
City of Edinburgh Council.
Y
T206
Letter from Scottish Executive re Approval of Structure Plan
Scottish Executive
Y
T207
Transport Scotland: White Paper
Scottish Executive
Y
T208
Traffic Flows
Halcrow Group
Y
T209
Article on Selfridges
Evening Standard
Y
T210
Congestion Charging on year one
Alon Carmel
Y
T211
Supplementary Statement by John Inman re Structure Plan
City of Edinburgh Council.
Y
T212
Noise Assessment - City Area - June 2004
Halcrow Group
Y
T213
Note on Burdiehouse Road
Transport Initiatives Edinburgh Ltd
Y
T214
Council Minute of 18 March 2004 re approval of objection report
City of Edinburgh Council.
Y
T215
Advertisement re referendum
Scotsman